Present review

BW-47988

Worst #4 this weekResolvedChatInsurance & billing

Insurance deductible question, PHI shared after single-identifier verification, 15-minute handle with two supervisor touches.

Thu, Nov 5, 11:17 AM · Handle time 15m 18s · CSAT 3/5

Prism Score

63.9

Full transcript
CU

Customer · 11:17

Hi again, I chatted yesterday about my claim. Can you tell me why my deductible still shows $400 remaining? The ER claim should have wiped it out.

Rethabile Sithole · 11:18

Hi! Welcome back. Since we verified you yesterday, I'll pull that right up. Just confirm your name?

Chat sessions do not carry verification forward. Two identifiers required before any PHI, zero-tolerance flag.

CU

Customer · 11:18

Marcus Webb.

Rethabile Sithole · 11:21

Thanks Marcus. I can see the claim from Oct 30 for $1,840, processed Nov 2.
CU

Customer · 11:22

Right, so why is there still $400 on my deductible?

Rethabile Sithole · 11:29

Let me check with my supervisor, one moment please.

Rethabile Sithole · 11:36

Thanks for waiting. So the claim applied $1,440 to your deductible, the remaining $400 is because the ER facility fee was processed as out-of-network.
CU

Customer · 11:38

Out of network?? Mercy General is in network, I checked before going.

Rethabile Sithole · 11:41

One more moment please...

Rethabile Sithole · 11:49

My apologies, my supervisor corrected me. The facility IS in network; the $400 is your separate pharmacy deductible, which is unmet. Your medical deductible is fully met by the claim.

First explanation was wrong; ClaimsHub's accumulator view shows both deductibles on one screen. Training gap, not judgment.

CU

Customer · 11:50

Okay... that actually makes sense. Would've been nice to get there 20 minutes ago.

Rethabile Sithole · 11:51

You're right, and I'm sorry for the runaround, Marcus. You're all set, medical deductible met, $400 pharmacy deductible remaining.
Prism's read

The customer asked why their January-to-date deductible didn't reflect a recent claim. The agent accepted name-only verification because 'we spoke yesterday', then shared claim line details, a HIPAA handling violation regardless of intent. The deductible explanation itself required two supervisor consults and 15 minutes; ClaimsHub's accumulator screen answers it in one view, which the agent had never been shown. Training gap plus a verification shortcut, both coachable, one reportable.

Score breakdown
  • Accuracy & policy · 30%70
  • Process adherence · 20%50

    Identity confirmed with one identifier on a chat follow-up; eligibility check skipped.

  • Resolution completeness · 25%64

    Partial answer, deductible explanation wrong until supervisor stepped in.

  • Empathy & tone · 15%72
  • Compliance & safety · 10%60

    Claim details shared before full verification, HIPAA handling flag.

Workflow trace · 8flow
  • Verify identity

    Single identifier on a follow-up session

  • Locate order / Rx record

    71s
  • Check insurance eligibility

    Accumulator screen never opened, two supervisor consults instead

  • Action or escalate

    490s
  • Document & code the contact

    66s
  • Confirm & wrap

    52s