Maya Reynolds
Brightwell Pharmacy
BW-48041
Worst #3 this weekReopenedEmailReturns & refundsExchange request answered with an unedited refund macro quoting the superseded 30-day window.
Mon, Nov 2, 4:08 PM · Handle time 5m 12s · CSAT 1/5
Prism Score
61.3
Customer · 16:08
Halima Suleiman · 16:54
Unedited macro RET-04 (retired policy). Customer asked for an exchange; answer describes a refund. 30-day window is wrong, v4.2 is 21 days for opened OTC.
Customer · 17:31
System · Nov 5, Ticket reopened and escalated after a public one-star review referencing this exchange.
Avoidable public-reputation damage; exchange was in stock and policy-eligible the whole time.
The customer asked to exchange a children's nebulizer for a different mask size, a straightforward swap under policy. The reply was the legacy refund macro: wrong policy window (30 days vs the current 21 for opened items), wrong process (refund steps, not exchange), and no acknowledgment of the context. The macro library still contains three superseded templates; this one has been used 41 times since Oct 1. Fix is systemic (retire the macros), not just individual.
- Accuracy & policy · 30%58
Return window stated as 30 days; v4.2 is 21 days for opened OTC items.
- Process adherence · 20%66
- Resolution completeness · 25%55
Macro answered the wrong question, customer asked about an exchange, not a refund.
- Empathy & tone · 15%62
Unedited macro; no acknowledgment the item was for a sick child.
- Compliance & safety · 10%88
Verify identity
22sLocate order / Rx record
47sCheck insurance eligibility
N/A, OTC purchase, correctly skipped
Action or escalate
Macro sent without reading the request
Document & code the contact
31sConfirm & wrap
No confirmation of what the customer actually asked
Coaching assigned from this week's review - see the plan