Present review

BW-48112

Worst #1 this weekReopenedChatInsurance & billing

Duplicate charge on a 90-day refill, wrong policy quoted, no eligibility check, unauthorized credit promised.

Wed, Nov 4, 2:22 PM · Handle time 12m 14s · CSAT 2/5

Prism Score

54.2

Full transcript
CU

Customer · 14:22

Hi, I've been charged twice for my metformin 90-day refill. $84 and then $84 again yesterday. Can someone explain?

Tariro Moyo · 14:23

Hello! So sorry about that, I understand how frustrating double charges can be. Let me look into this right away.

Tariro Moyo · 14:24

Can you confirm the name on the account and your date of birth?
CU

Customer · 14:24

Robert Hayes, 03/14/1961.

Tariro Moyo · 14:27

Thanks Robert. I can see the order BW-88291 for $84. And yes, I see a second $84 posted yesterday.

ClaimsHub never opened, the second posting was an insurance resubmission hold, visible in step 3 of the SOP.

CU

Customer · 14:28

So it IS a double charge. I'm on a fixed income, I need that back.

Tariro Moyo · 14:31

I completely understand. Our policy says duplicate charges are refunded within 3-5 days, and I can also add a $42 goodwill credit for the trouble.

Policy v4.2 (effective Oct 1) does not authorize goodwill credits for billing disputes, superseded policy quoted. Unauthorized financial commitment.

CU

Customer · 14:32

Okay... so the refund is confirmed? Can you read me back the card it goes to? Ends in 4471?

Tariro Moyo · 14:33

Yes, the Visa ending 4471, charged on 11/03, refund will go back to that card.

Card detail echoed in chat body, payment references must stay in the tokenized panel.

CU

Customer · 14:34

Great. And the $42 credit shows up when?

Tariro Moyo · 14:35

Both should appear within 3-5 business days. Anything else I can help with today?
CU

Customer · 14:35

No, that covers it. Thanks for sorting it.

System · 14:36, Ticket closed as Resolved, coded 'Order status & shipping'.

Miscoded: this is a Billing contact. Prism re-coded from transcript.

System · Nov 6, Ticket reopened by customer: 'No refund, no credit, and now I'm told the second $84 was insurance? Nobody knows what's going on.'

Reopen within 7 days, the resubmission hold released on its own; the promised credit was invalid.

Prism's read

The customer contacted about a visible duplicate charge. The agent never opened ClaimsHub to confirm whether the second charge was an insurance resubmission (it was), quoted the superseded returns policy, and committed to a $42 credit that policy v4.2 reserves for shipping faults. The customer returned two days later angrier, with the credit unhonoured. Root cause is process, not intent: this is the exact deviation pattern 8flow flags on Monday-morning queue spikes.

Score breakdown
  • Accuracy & policy · 30%42

    Quoted the pre-October returns policy; promised a credit that policy v4.2 does not allow.

  • Process adherence · 20%48

    Insurance eligibility never checked in ClaimsHub before discussing the charge.

  • Resolution completeness · 25%51

    Customer left without an answer on the duplicate charge; ticket reopened in 2 days.

  • Empathy & tone · 15%78

    Tone was warm but apologized in place of resolving.

  • Compliance & safety · 10%71

    Partial card number read back in chat, should use tokenized flow.

Workflow trace · 8flow
  • Verify identity

    41s
  • Locate order / Rx record

    66s
  • Check insurance eligibility

    ClaimsHub never opened during the interaction (8flow)

  • Action or escalate

    Credit promised outside policy instead of escalating

  • Document & code the contact

    Miscoded as Order status

  • Confirm & wrap

    48s